Cic edizioni internazionali
Il Giornale di Chirurgia

Mapping the centers performing endocrine neck surgery in Italy

Original Articles, 389 - 397
Tag this article
Full text PDF
Background. Quality of care and provider’s experience seem to be strictly connected in any field of surgery. Aim of this study is to identify a method to classify the centers on the basis of the number of thyroidectomies and parathyroidectomies performed.
Methods. We listed 666 centers performing endocrine neck surgery in 2015, from the database of the Italian Health Ministry. We performed a descriptive statistic analysis with a dedicated software. We identified the outliers, according to a previous literature review, in those centers performing >1000 and < 10 thyroidectomies, >100 and < 3 parathyroidectomies and we excluded them to our analysis. The remaining centers were grouped in a box-plot. Third quartile, median, procedures performed/3rd quartile value ratio (Standardized Hospitalization Ratio, SHR, superior cut-off), Romamedian/3rd quartile values ratio (inferior cut-off) were calculated. These centers were charted in a bar graph and three zones were identified: “excellence” (SHR>1.1), “SHR”, “alert” (between the two cut-offs) and “risk” (under the lower cut-off).
Results. 35743 thyroidectomies and 2306 parathyroidectomies were performed in Italy in 2015. After the outliers’ exclusion, 407 and 157 centers performing respectively thyroidectomies and parathyroidectomies were analysed. A median value of respectively 37 thyroidectomies and 6 parathyroidectomies, and a 3rd quartile cut-off of respectively 85 and 12 were calculated. Concerning all the 666 centers, we found: 95 excellence centers for thyroidectomy and 33 for parathyroidectomy, respectively 18 and 17 falling into superior cut-off line, 100 and 29 in the alert zone, 453 and 587 in the risk zone.
Conclusions. Our method, according to the literature data, highlighted a number of thyroidectomies and parathyroidectomies performed in low volume centers. Looking for an optimization in health organization, we can consider some measures such as a net of tutorship of the “alert” hospitals by the excellence ones and a discouragement of the “risk” hospitals in performing endocrine neck surgery.

Vol. XLI (No. 1) 2020 January - February

  1. Laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass in the treatment of obesity: evidence based update through randomized clinical trials and meta-analyses
    Morales-Maza J., Rodriguez-Quintero J.H., Sanchez-Morales G.E., Sanchez Garcia-Ramos E., Romero-Velez G., Aguilar-Frasco J.L., Pimienta-Ibarra A.S., Alvarez-Bautista F.E., Leon P., Hernandez-Acevedo J.D., Del Angel-Millan G., Sierra M.
  2. Retroperitoneal sarcomas: from diagnosis to treatment. Case series and review of the literature
    Mantas D., Garmpis N., Polychroni D., Garmpi A., Damaskos C., Liakea A., Sypsa G., Kouskos E.
  3. The discriminative properties of erythrocyte anisocytosis in patients with resectable malignant pancreatic masses compared with an age and gender matched control group
    Akturk O.M., Çakir M.
  4. Diagnostic and therapeutic role of laparoscopy in perforated peptic ulcer in the elderly patients
    Giordano A., Prosperi P., Alemanno G., Bergamini C., Bruscino A., Valeri A.
  5. The role of laparoscopic surgery in isolated adrenal metastasis: our personal experience
    Frattolillo G., Paradiso G., Scarano Catanzaro V., Giordano L., Avantifiori R., D'Ermo G., Letizia C., De Toma G.
  6. Advances in bioengineering of complex tissues: state of the art of mucosae decellularization protocols
    Rizzo M.I., Contardi C., Esposito M., Zama M.
  7. An analysis of missed cases with surgical emergencies admitted in non-surgical departments. Case series and а review of the literature
    Popivanov G., Cirocchi R., Popov G., Stefanovski P., Andonova R., Kjossev K., Tonchev P., Tabakov M., Penkov M., Ivanov P., Mutafchiyski V.
  8. The evolution of robotic arm-assisted arthroplasty in Greece
    Koutserimpas C., Dretakis K.
  9. Current role of open surgery in adrenal tumors
    Chiappini A., Frattolillo G., Paradiso G., De Gori A., Scarano Catanzaro V., Avantifiori R., Fiori E., De Toma G.
  10. Preoperative fasting - “nihil per os” a difficult myth to break down: a randomized controlled study
    Panebianco A., Laforgia R., Volpi A., Punzo C., Vacca G., Minafra M., Di Salvo M., Pezzolla A.
  11. Sentinel lymph node biopsy with intraoperative touch imprint cytology (TIC) in breast cancer: experience of a mild-volume center
    Marano A., Sodano B., Vitiello C., Martini A.M., Baldassarre F., Siciliano A., Iannaci G.
  12. Spontaneous transdiaphragmatic intercostal hernia: clinical considerations and management
    Lonardo M.T., Frezzotti F., Collalti M., Natili A., Metere A.
  13. Systemic immune response after open tension-free inguinal hernia repair under different anesthetic alternatives: a prospective comparative study
    Symeonidis D., Diamantis A., Baloyiannis I., Tzovaras G., Tepetes K.
  14. Minilaparotomic incision for haemorrhagic corpus luteum: a case report
    Leanza V., Mininni C., Di Grazia F.M., Genovese F., Carbonaro A., Leanza G., Palumbo M.
  15. Conservative management of streptococcal necrotizing periorbital fasciitis following primary VZV infection
    Kontou E., Bontzos G., Triantafyllou D., Garnavou-Xirou C., Ragkousis A., Xirou T.
  16. Relief of hemorrhoid symptoms: pilot study of a new topical ally
    Gaj F., Bianchi F.P., Passannanti D., Tedesco D.
  17. Topical use of tranexamic acid in primary total knee arthroplasty: a comparative study
    Besiris G.TH., Koutserimpas C., Karamitros A., Karaiskos I., Tsakalou D., Raptis K., Kourelis K., Paxinos O., Kotsirakis A., Vlasis K.
  18. Insights in clinical examination and diagnosis of Athletic Pubalgia
    Koutserimpas C., Ioannidis A., Konstantinidis M.K., Makris M.C., Antonakopoulos F., Mazarakis A., Papagelopoulos P.J., Vlasis K., Konstantinidis M.K.
Last Viewed articles: la lista degli ultimi x visitati.
  1. Mapping the centers performing endocrine neck surgery in Italy
    Scerrino G., Melfa G., Raspanti C., Attard A., Mazzola S., Porrello C., Tutino R., Fontana T., Paladino N.C., Gulotta E., Salamone G., Cocorullo G.